The Ottawa Senators are for sale.
No, not the organization just the roster. And man do they need help. It isn’t just the NHL roster that is lacking in depth, talent, and winning drive. Their AHL affiliate the Bellville Senators are near the bottom of that league as well. Without a first or second round pick this year, and a third round pick next year, this team can not afford to move players and not get solid returns.
Given the questionable ability of the organization to draft and develop players, a case can be made for the team to trade exclusively for roster players and prospects who would be in the NHL if it weren’t for their current rights holder having salary cap issues. I don’t know that this is a good idea, but with the number of NHL players on teams well outside the playoffs who might be able to help the organization going forward it isn’t an idea that can be dismissed entirely.
While everyone else is analyzing if the organization should move on from Erik Karlsson, and what they can get for him, I’ll stick to some of the players who have value as depth players, or to fill in for a top six/top four player who is expected to be out for an extended period.
Jean-Gabriel Pageau is a sneaky good depth forward. Last year he produced 19 goals in the regular season and then eight more in the Senator’s playoff appearance. He produces at even strength, and on the penalty kill. Any team needing either a 3rd center or first pairing penalty kill forward will get a good value. Value: 2nd round pick plus, likely a 2nd and a lesser pick or prospect.
Mark Borowiecki overshadowed by both Karlsson and Phanuef on this roster. His raw physicality will lead some to overlook his skating ability, a good comparison is Boston’s Kevan Miller. Value: This one is tricky, he’s got a team friendly contract, two more years on it, but is never going to be even a middling points producer. A 3rd or 4th round pick would seam fair but I could see him going for more.
Mike Hoffman. I think the Ottawa Senator’s organization would be fools to trade him, but he is undoubtedly a quality goal scorer able to produce his own offense in a system with limited assistance. He’s under contract for next season as well. Value: 1st round pick plus additional return.
Johnny Oduya: May end up as a throw in with a bigger name, might go somewhere looking for a veteran who has been there and done that. He’s not going to come in a play top pairing minutes, but veteran defensemen are valued above the purely on ice contribution, particularly ones who have been as far into the playoffs as he has. Value: will likely fetch a 2nd or a lesser prospect.
Mark Stone is quietly having a good season for the Senators, and will like getting a significant raise on July 1. With 18 goals already on a team that’s subpar and coached defense first, he’s going to generate some interest. Value: This will depend entirely on if he is just traded as a rental or if there is a signing involved in the move. A pair of second round picks say 2018 and 2020 would be a nice return.
Derick Brassard on the plus side has already matched last year’s goal total, on the minus side he’s not young any more and a $2,500,000 signing bonus just for living until bonus day might slow down the clamor the talents of the soon to be 31 year old Quebec native. Value: Roster player (either expiring contract or need for need) and a pick.